Was Race, Age or Hair The Reason for Pam Oliver's Demotion?

I’m a fanatical football fan. And I’m also a huge fan of Pam Oliver.

For nearly two decades, I’ve watched Oliver talk football on Fox television I’ll miss her sideline analysis, real-time insights, and conversational halftime interviews with the NFL’s top players. I watched with pride as Oliver, a skilled African-American journalist, excelled in a cutthroat profession dominated by white men.

All television assignments ultimately come to an end, but when news broke last week that Oliver, 53, the No. 1 sideline reporter for Fox NFL coverage, will be replaced after 19 years by Erin Andrews, a 36-year-old blonde, some folks immediately wondered if Oliver’s hair controversy contributed to her demotion.

I’m not up on hair trends, but I do know that critics on social media can be cruel. Some have compared Oliver’s hairstyle to Chewbacca, the wild-haired alien in the movie “Star Wars,” and others frequently took Oliver to task for looking disheveled on live national television.

I don’t know if criticism of Oliver’s hair concerned executives at Fox, but I did find it hypocritical that some Black folks who were scolding Oliver for her hairstyle are now criticizing Fox for replacing Oliver with Andrews.

Some have questioned if race played a role in Oliver’s move from the sidelines. It’s no secret that male executives prefer younger women on-air and Fox officials no doubt wanted Andrews because she’s 17 years younger than Oliver. Still, Oliver looks great for 53, despite the hair controversy and she’s a known entity to both viewers and players.

Others insist that Oliver’s demotion is a Fox misstep on the issue of diversity. But does Fox really care?

A veteran NFL reporter told Sports Illustrated that Oliver was demoted because she didn’t fit the look that Fox executives desired.

“She’s not blonde, nor is she in the demographic,” said the reporter. “I’m not naïve and I understand it’s a business, but I think that Fox did not treat her as befits a woman who has been the female face of their sports operation for the past 19 years.”

Meanwhile, Fox executives insisted their decision was not about race and the network released this statement:

Pam is one of the most respected reporters in the industry, and her being part of the FOX family now and in the future is really important to us, which is why we signed her to a new three year contract. We’ve developed what’s clearly an expanded role for Pam that better meets the needs of FOX Sports and FOX Sports 1 and the big events we cover, while enabling her to work on many of our big NFL games throughout the season. Pam’s new role helps us build our journalistic chops and credibility 365 days a year, not just 17. Our decision had absolutely nothing to do with race or age.

Oliver took the high road.

“Disappointment is not really a word I’d use right now because I’ve had some weeks to process it,” Oliver said in a recent interview with Sports Illustrated.

“I think my emotions during the season will be sadness because I had been around that group for a decade,” she said. “I went through a range of emotions, but as I speak with you today, disappointment has passed me and I have reached a point of trying to move forward with some sadness.”

Oliver’s new contract will allow her to enjoy an expanded role at the network, which includes high-profile interviews with sports superstars. She also said she’s excited about the new position.

Whether that’s true or not, who really knows.

Most men I know feel that Oliver is an attractive, smart and talented journalist who brings a wealth of knowledge to the game of football.

With all the outstanding interviews Oliver has delivered for Fox, I believe executives should have allowed her to finish out her 20^th year as their No. 1 sideline reporter.

It was a hasty decision to remove Oliver from her highly-visible job and I’ll miss her keen observations on Sunday afternoons – hairstyle issues or not.

What do you think?

Like BlackAmericaWeb.com on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter.